Evaluating Business Culture – Where is your line?
There are some core questions that most people will ask when they are trying to understand the culture of a team or an organisation.
These tend to focus around:
• The purpose
• How decisions are made
• What behaviours are rewarded
• Styles of communication and levels of transparency
• How performance is incentivised
Questions that get little attention but can be wonderfully revealing are:
• What do you discipline employees for?
• What would an employee have to do to get dismissed from this place?
• Where is your corporate line – what is too much and will not be tolerated?
Organisations with strong values and positive cultures will often take great pride in telling you that they never use their disciplinary procedures. They “can’t remember the last time someone was given a formal warning“. This invokes a feeling in me akin to that when a fellow parent tells me that they have never raised their voice at their children. It isn’t that I don’t believe it. It isn’t that I don’t respect the choice they’ve made in terms of their stylistic approach to wrongdoing (carrot vs stick, and all that).
However, it tells me much more about the parent than the children. Yet it often comes with a suggestion that this speaks to the children’s behaviour as opposed to the parent’s choice of response. Similarly, managers and leaders who claim never to have used a disciplinary warning seem to believe that this tells me something about their employees. It does not.
It could be that the organisation promotes a coaching rather than a corrective style of management; it could be that the unions are strong and contentious; management are remote or ‘hands-off’ or reluctant to address issues formally because they fear push-back or are hyper sensitive to allegations of inequity. Maybe they don’t know how to manage a formal process? Whatever the reason, it is always more revealing of the managers and the culture of the organisation than of the employees.
Where the formal procedures are routinely applied, I get access to a back catalogue of minor and major offences and can see how seriously these were taken. I get to see what the approach to consistency, conflict, forgiveness, restitution, and failure really looks like.
It is always fascinating: how closely does the evidence of the reality match the stated aims and values of the organisation? Is confidentiality prioritised over learning and sharing? How diligently and objectively are processes applied and records kept? How long do processes take to complete? Has a sanction ever been successfully appealed?
Often there are themes…
Many robust responses to technical breaches of policy that seem harsh to the outsider but may identify a strong safety culture
Regular warnings for timekeeping and attendance which might suggest problems with presenteeism and/or a lack of trust between managers and employees
Most issues treated informally unless an external client or customer raises the issue and then serious repercussions always follow? This could indicate a greater focus on reputational risk than values and behaviours
Records of past investigations can reveal how strongly different voices within an organisation are listened to and where the real power lies
Repetitive sanctioning for similar issues suggests an unwillingness to explore the real triggers for misbehaviour or lack of desire to consider institutional failings and implement measures for lasting change such as a formal performance management process
Frequent dismissals of short-serving employees should raise questions over recruitment and on-boarding processes, and the ethical approach to hiring and firing
Values-driven organisations where integrity of purpose is prized tend to recruit thoughtfully and dismiss rarely. That said, when a ‘red line’ is crossed, the leaders don’t flinch. It is unlikely to hear talk of reputational risk or commercial realities to justify not invoking the ultimate sanction. They clearly define the boundaries between acceptable and unacceptable behaviour and where a serious breach occurs, dismissal is treated as a moral obligation. It is unusual to see any distinctions made for status. Similarly, such dismissals are rarely hushed up or dealt with in confidential settlements. Transparency about these decisions is seen as an opportunity to reinforce the values. There is a confidence and a pride in being clear on what they will and won’t tolerate.
Knowing what truly irks a business leader, what they really consider unforgivable has always seemed to be a better way to get to know someone than to listen to their endless positioning of likes.
Find out where their line is, and you will learn far more.
Jane Wilson and Leah De Vries – Teal Street HR&L Consultancy www.tealstreet.co.uk
