Do you segment or integrate?

An interesting notion when thinking about our current working lives.

In the old world I frequently observed both types:

To segment – a clear divide between work and home life, little discussion of personal situations with work colleagues all business, often dressing formally to create a difference, shedding the sharp suit at the end of the working day.  Many traditional businesses have thrived on people taking this divided approach and having to juggle behind the scenes to allow life to occur without impacting on the workplace.  Taking holidays for dentist’s appointments, never asking to leave early and being fully present when at work.

To integrate – in my experience until about 10 years ago this only occurred with people who ran their own businesses, working out the boot of their car, always available to take calls, working weekends, working from home involved friends and family in a loose and fluid.  Nipping off for hair appointments and sports day as needed and working evenings and weekends to fit things in.

Both approaches have advantages and disadvantages, and we were free to choose, but our new world order has forced us into a blurred approach.  But at what cost?

Those in favour of segmented found the approach easier to manage, no need to share uncomfortable truths in the workplace, easy to follow a formal dress code and not worry about being appropriate or true to yourself – this all happened at the weekend.  But of course, this also maintains the status quo and we are replicating the generation before and following their rules.

Those in favour of integrated could enjoy the fact that it allows you to be yourself, no coincidence that dotcom tycoons chose a dress down approach to clothing and a more relaxed way of working when given the choice.  Current conditions mean we can easily spend the day in pyjamas and slippers if we chose to – but are we being true to ourselves and are we being productive?  It is certainly the case that for the c19 million households in the UK with children currently off school, that there is no option but to blur the boundaries, but this is stressful.  Many studies have shown how much harder it is to concentrate when multitasking and when your concentration is repeatedly broken.  How many of us have the luxury of a quiet office space??? If only….

To conclude then an interesting point to reflect on the benefits of each and the elements you might want to maintain or reject as we move into the new world of working.

Jane