Weighing it all up – Employment Law and HR which view is right?
An interesting tension exists between what a business can do, i.e. what employment law allows them to do legally, and what they may want to do – what speaks of their culture and how they want to be perceived.
People decision makers in a business – be they HR professionals, accidental line managers or business owners – frequently have to balance the options of what they can do with what they want to do or what feels right for them.
Employment lawyers may helpfully let you know what the law says, what is possible and what you should not do. Their risk equation will often focus quite narrowly on the specific case (person!) rather than the team or organisation as a whole.
An HR expert will give you ideas of what might work for you, what other businesses have done and help you navigate the murky waters of what is likely to happen if you chose option a, b or c.
As a business manager you will be uniquely placed to balance these two views to decide what feels right for you and your organisation given the circumstances you are presented with. It is often helpful to not have a legal or HR background to do this effectively.
-
Non employment lawyers can expect a need for “beyond reasonable doubt” decisions which means the evidence needed is onerous, overly legalistic and simply not reasonable for a small business to achieve.
-
Lawyers can also hide behind the law, seeking comfort in what is possible rather than what is right – the gut feel. They might assess an individual case as low risk and say “sack them and we can sort it out for you” – without due consideration for the consequences on the individual, the team and the widerbusiness.
-
HR people can be guilty of leaning on their favourite crutch – the policy. If the handbook or policy says it, it must be done. Rather than taking a more practical, risky and case by case approach. They can be rigid in their views and overly concerned about not setting a precedent and avoiding risk at all costs.
-
Many HR professionals will break into a cold sweat at the idea of a light touch handbook with very few formal processes listed – their safety net is process.
-
The lawyer’s safety net is the law and precedents – what is legal and what would land you in a tribunal and what the costs of that would be in a specific case.
As a business owner and line manager you need to navigate both views to find the right way forward. Not always easy but gut feel, natural justice – what feels right and fair – is a really good starting point.
Just make sure you check the law and your handbook first!
Jane Wilson and Leah De Vries – Teal Street HR&L Consultancy www.tealstreet.co.uk
