The Informal Approach – all mouth no action? 

When serious issues arise in a business related to performance, standards of behaviour or team dynamics, people can often fall into one of two camps – the quiet chat or the formal process. 

Many managers have successfully and skillfully handled teams by ensuring a quick private chat when needed keeps people on track. A paternalistic (let’s face it: fairly masculine) and old school approach to work issues would be to take them out for lunch and let them know how the land lies. Some managers deploy this technique with everything, from 

· you are next for promotion; to 

· watch the gossip; and even 

· time to pack your bags and find something else 

not all in the same conversation of course… and all with a smile and a ‘I think we understand each other’ view of the world. 

A manager who knows their team may feel they can handle all issues with a quick chat and a nudge back on the right course, but what if the issues raised are serious? Perhaps even illegal or seriously impacting on a colleague or the business as a whole? 

Managers favouring the formal route may feel that significant issues should be handled by HR and a business leader and that the collegiate approach wouldn’t be suitable and could tarnish or detour a process unhelpfully.   They may also try to pass responsibility for handling the issue to someone else.

Perhaps neither of these approaches are helpful – an informal discussion by the manager within a structure could be the next right step when issues occur. It is worth remembering that informal conversations have value too – provided they are structured and noted. 

For example, when something more serious arises or an issue recurs, we would recommend a line manager takes the following steps:

1. Informal chat about the issues as part of a regular monthly 1:1 or separately 

2. Use a day book (real or e-version) – noting down 1:1s and any issues raised by the team – a short bullet point note of a discussion is all that is needed. 

3. Clearly set out the issue and ask the team member their thoughts, note this 

4. Agree next steps for any action or change of behaviours/approach and a date for a follow up 

5. Do a short email to follow up on the meeting in a positive and sensitive (non-threatening) tone – this sets down the discussion and if needed could form the basis of a formal process 

6. Diarise the follow up and review the conversation again with a note 

7. Follow up with an email and confirm any next steps 

8. At this stage if the issue isn’t resolved then have a conversation with a senior manager or HR lead to understand what next steps might be if needed – they will be delighted to see you have taken notes and started a clear process with the individual. 

An informal approach can be a vital first step in setting out expectations with an employee and provides enough structure to allow a line manager to raise and tackle issues in an appropriate manner. 

Why not try the informal approach and consider it part of your formal policy?

To learn more about this viewpoint why not try our free taster course on this very subject – available now at www.tealstreetacademy.co.uk

Thanks for reading

Jane Wilson and Leah De Vries – Teal Street HR&L Consultancy www.tealstreet.co.uk